← Tales from the TrailThursday's Untold Stories · By Corey Moser

Two Cowboys, a Bag of Diamonds, and a Million-Dollar Secret

A bag of diamonds, a secret location, and investors who wanted to believe. In the Old West, even a fortune in the dirt could come with a catch.

Two cowboys holding a bag of diamonds in San Francisco, with the episode title and The Roundup logo

An edited reading edition of Corey’s original episode, not a verbatim transcript. Listen to the story →

In 1872, two ordinary fellows from Kentucky managed to convince some of the richest men in America that they'd discovered a diamond mine worth a fortune. They had actual diamonds to prove it. They took experts out to the mine, and those experts found diamonds too. There was just one small problem.

Their names were Philip Arnold and John Slack. They were cousins, prospectors, and apparently pretty good at separating wealthy men from their money. Back in those days, everybody was looking for the next big discovery. Gold, silver, you name it.

If there was a chance of getting rich digging something out of the ground, somebody was willing to invest in it. So when these two fellas showed up in San Francisco carrying a bag of uncut diamonds, they got people's attention in a hurry. They claimed they'd discovered an enormous deposit somewhere in the American West, but they wouldn't tell anybody exactly where. Naturally, that made everybody even more interested.

Eventually, Arnold and Slack agreed to take a group of investors and a respected mining expert out to see their secret diamond field. They traveled into the rugged country near what's now the Colorado-Wyoming border. When the investors started looking around, wouldn't you know it? They found diamonds.

Can you imagine the excitement? These wealthy businessmen thought they'd stumbled onto one of the greatest fortunes in American history. There was talk of millions of dollars. Arnold and Slack stood to walk away with a considerable fortune themselves.

Now you're probably wondering how two prospectors from Kentucky managed to discover a diamond mine nobody else had ever found. Well, here's the part I like. They didn't. They'd taken money from their investors, traveled to London, and purchased thousands of dollars' worth of gemstones.

Then they hauled those stones back across the ocean, took them out into the middle of nowhere, and scattered them around in the dirt. They didn't discover a diamond mine. They decorated the desert. Somehow, they'd convinced some of the smartest and wealthiest businessmen in America that those rocks had been sitting there for thousands of years.

But they hadn't counted on a geologist named Clarence King. King was working on a government geological survey when he heard about the discovery. Something didn't sit right with him. So he went out to investigate.

There were gemstones together that didn't belong together geologically. Some stones were sitting in places where nature was highly unlikely to have left them. There was evidence that some supposedly untouched gemstones had already been worked by jewelers. King realized the entire diamond field had been planted.

When the truth came out, the whole scheme collapsed. The investors had been fooled, and Arnold and Slack had already made off with substantial amounts of money. These two fellas hadn't needed to convince the entire world. They'd only needed a handful of people who desperately wanted to believe they'd found something extraordinary.

The more money those investors thought they could make, the less closely they seemed to look. I suppose some things haven't changed much in 150 years. Whether it's diamonds in the desert or the next can't-miss opportunity, there's always somebody willing to sell you a fortune that hasn't been found yet. Sometimes the biggest treasure in the whole operation is the money you brought with you.